We like to make our own birthday cakes, and this is the second time that we’ve tackled the Pixar’s Cars theme this year. The first time Michael made a model of the race track, but he wasn’t pleased with the results. This time he made a model of Lightning McQueen and he is much happier with how the cake turned out. Our boys liked the cake so much that the very next day our 3-year-old started asking Daddy to make Mater for his birthday cake. “Mommy, you make the cake, and Daddy, you decorate it!” he commanded in his sweet excited voice. He still asks every day even though his birthday isn’t until June!
This birthday celebration was for our oldest, who turned 5 in November. He requested a Lightning McQueen cake and wanted the flavor to be yellow. I’ve tried a lot of yellow butter cake recipes, but so many of them just don’t have a good texture or flavor. For this cake I tried the All-Purpose Buttery Yellow Cake recipe in my America’s Test Kitchen Family Cookbook, and I have to say we were very pleased with it. The cake was built with three 9×13 layers, graham crackers, and chocolate covered donuts, then covered with red butter cream frosting and detailed with more butter cream and a few pieces of fondant. This was one large cake and it could easily serve 28 people or more depending on how you cut the pieces. For a smaller cake, you can use mini chocolate covered donuts and just two 9×13 layers. We used a Fisher-Price Shake ‘n Go™ Lightning McQueen as the model for the cake.
As with our previous cakes, this one is 100% edible, though you can skip eating the fondant pieces if you want. The marshmallow fondant tastes better than regular fondant, but we’re not fans. Still, fondant is the way to go if you need a very smooth surface on a cake, and it works well in the few places we needed it for Lightening McQueen. We used Wilton gel colors and basic liquid food coloring for both the butter cream and the fondant. Michael tried to make as much detail as possible, though at 2 am he was getting a bit tired!
You can make the cakes and frosting a day ahead, and the cakes actually handle better if you let them sit overnight. Keep the frosting in the refrigerator until you are ready to use it, and then allow it to come to room temperature before attempting to decorate the cake, otherwise it will be too stiff to work with. We tried a new butter cream recipe this year and we *love* it because it uses heavy cream and unsalted butter, no shortening. The flavor is so much better. The only disclaimer is for temperature and humidity. In hot humid weather, a pure butter frosting will start to soften and separate and even run down the cake, which is why the shortening is added because it acts as a stabilizer. In cool weather, I say go for the pure butter cream!
The butter cake and the butter cream frosting recipes are adapted from my America’s Test Kitchen Family Cookbook, and the marshmallow fondant recipe was posted in the Wilton.com forums. The cake recipe makes one 9×13 cake, so you’ll need to mix two or three batches depending on how large you make your cake. The butter cream recipe makes three cups, and you’ll need two to three batches of it. We cheated a bit by using plain white frosting in between the cake layers rather than making more red, but you can certainly use red frosting if you prefer.
Notes About Red Frosting
The red frosting is challenging because it’s hard to make a really deep red, and you can go through an entire jar of Wilton Red for just one cup of frosting. Because you are making a large amount of frosting and need the red to be as deep as possible, you’ll want to use the No-Taste Red which doesn’t have FD&C red #3, otherwise the frosting will take on a bitter flavor. Here are some tips to help deepen the color of your red frosting:
- Trying making pink frosting first, then start adding the red gel. You won’t need as much red as you would if you started from white frosting.
- Make and color the frosting a day or two ahead and let it sit. The colors deepen with time.
- If you have a cake and candy supply store near you, ask if they have Ameri-color or Chefmaster Liquid Gel colors. These are more concentrated and take less gel to make a deep red.
- I’ve also seen tips for using maraschino cherry juice in the red frosting. I’ve tried it with cookies, but I have not tried it in frosting. The juice is usually sweetened and the color is somewhat thin, but it would add both color and flavor. Take care not to add too much, or you might end up with runny frosting.
Adapted from America’s Test Kitchen Family Cookbook.
2 or 3 (9×13-inch) cake pans, lightly coated with cooking spray and lined with parchment in the bottom
stand mixer with paddle attachment
Ingredients (Make two or three batches, one batch for each layer.)
2-3/4 cups cake flour
2 1/2 teaspoons baking powder
3/4 teaspoon salt
2 sticks (1 cup) unsalted butter, softened
1-3/4 cup granulated sugar
4 large eggs, at room temperature
1 tablespoon vanilla extract
1-1/2 cups whole milk, at room temperature
1. Preheat oven to 350° F.
2. Stir together the cake flour, baking powder, and salt in the medium bowl and set aside.
3. In the bowl of the stand mixer, beat together the sugar and butter until it is light and fluffy, about 6 minutes. Add each egg one at a time and beat in. Scrape down the sides of the bowl as you go. Beat in the vanilla extract.
4. Add 1/3 of the flour mixture, beating on low speed. Add 1/2 of the milk and beat in. Add half of the remaining flour mixture, beating in, then the remaining milk. Finally add the remaining flour mixture and beat in.
5. Use a rubber spatula to scrape down the sides of the bowl and stir into the batter. Pour into the prepared pan and bake until a toothpick comes out clean, about 25 to 30 minutes.
6. Remove from the oven and allow cake to rest in pan for about 10 minutes, sitting on a wire rack. Run a plastic knife around the edges, then turn the cake out onto the wire rack and then turn it back over upright. Allow to cool completely, about 1 to 2 hours.
I made each cake one at a time and baked them as soon as they were mixed so that the batter did not deflate, which it tends to do if the batter sits for too long before baking.
Set the eggs, butter, and milk out about 30 minutes before mixing so that they have time to come to room temperature.
BUTTER CREAM FROSTING
Adapted from America’s Test Kitchen Family Cookbook.
stand mixer with paddle attachment
4 small bowls
1 medium bowl
toothpicks (for dipping the gel colors)
popsicle sticks (for stirring the colored frosting)
food service gloves (optional), helps keep your hands color free
Ingredients (Make two or three batches, one for each layer.)
2 tablespoons heavy cream
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
pinch of salt
2-1/2 sticks unsalted butter, softened
2-1/2 cups confectioners sugar
Wilton No-Taste Red, 2 bottles
Wilton Sky Blue
1. In a small bowl, stir together the heavy cream, vanilla extract, and the salt.
2. In the bowl of the stand mixer, beat the butter on medium-high speed until it’s smooth, just about 1 minute.
3. Reduce speed to low and slowly add the confectioners sugar, about 1/2 cup at a time. Beat until smooth, about 5 minutes.
4. Add the cream mixture and beat on medium-high until the frosting is light and fluffy. ATK says about 4 to 8 minutes, it took about 8 minutes for me.
5. RED Frosting: Put 5-1/2 cups of the plain frosting in the medium bowl. (Adjust the amount based on the number of layers, about 1-3/4 cups per layer.) Using toothpicks and popsicle sticks, start adding the No-Taste Red gel coloring a little at a time, stirring as you go until you have a deep bright red. By the time we were done, we had used two bottles of color. This only makes enough red frosting to cover the outside of the cake. If you want red frosting in between the cake layers, you’ll need to add another cup or two, one for each frosting layer.
6. ORANGE Frosting: Put 1/4 cup of the plain frosting in a small bowl. Using toothpicks and popsicle sticks, add the orange gel coloring a little at a time, stirring as you go until you have the desired color.
7. BLUE Frosting: Put 1-1/2 cups of the plain frosting in a small bowl. Using toothpicks and popsicle sticks, add the Sky Blue gel coloring a little at a time, stirring as you go until you have the desired color.
8. BLACK Frosting: Put 1/4 cup of the plain frosting in a small bowl. Using toothpicks and popsicle sticks, add the Black gel coloring a little at a time, stirring as you go until you have a deep black.
9. You will have some white frosting left over. We used it in between the cake layers as well as in places where a little “frosting glue” was needed.
Some of the measurements for coloring the frosting are approximated because we started off making just two batches of the frosting then had to make another when we ran out. We tried to over estimate because it’s better to have a little extra (which tastes really good with graham crackers) than not enough.
Adapted from a post on Wilton.com forums.
large microwave safe bowl OR 3-quart pot
toothpick (for dipping the gel color)
1 cup mini marshmallows, packed well
1 tablespoon water
1-1/2 to 1-3/4 cup confectioners sugar
1. Put the mini marshmallows in the microwave safe bowl and add the water. Cook in the microwave for 20 seconds, just until they soften and look puffy. If you prefer to do it on the stove, put the marshmallows in a 3-quart pot and add the water. Cook and stir over medium-low heat until the marshmallows look soupy.
2. Add the confectioners sugar and stir using the silicone spatula until the mixture is fully incorporated and no longer sticky. It will get stiff.
3. Sprinkle more confectioners sugar on a work surface and spoon the marshmallow mixture onto the surface. Coat your hands with confectioners sugar and knead the dough until it is smooth, about 5 minutes.
4. BROWN: Cut off about 1/4 cup of the fondant and mash it with your hands. Add Wilton Brown gel color a little at a time and knead it in with your hands. The color will look streaked at first, then will become more consistent as you work it.
5. WHITE: Set aside the remaining fondant.
6. If you make the fondant a day or more ahead, roll the pieces into balls and wrap each piece tightly in plastic wrap and store in zip plastic bags to keep it fresh. Do not refrigerate. If it’s well-wrapped, this marshmallow fondant will keep at room temperature for up to 3 months.
serrated bread knife
X-Acto craft knife (for cutting the fondant)
plastic drinking straws
plastic lids about the same size as the donuts
4 (1-quart) freezer bags
decorating tips (five #3 and two #12) and couplers
angled spatula, for spreading frosting
prepared and cooled layer cakes
4 chocolate covered donuts (medium to large for a 3-layer cake, minis for a 2-layer cake) *We used Entenmann’s Donuts because they have the chocolate donuts in two sizes.
3 graham cracker halves
1. CAKES: Level the top of the cakes as necessary using a serrated bread knife.
2. Place the one cake on your cake plate, cut side down. Spread a layer of white frosting on top. Add another layer, cut side down. (Spread another layer of white frosting on top if you are doing a 3-layer cake, then add the top layer.)
3. Using the serrated knife, cut away parts of the cake to shape it. Carve the top to make the windows. Cut the front at a downward angle. Cut the back in a shape that angles up from the windows toward the back fin (air dam). The back side has a bit of curve from the top middle down towards the wheels. Make sure all of the corners are rounded.
4. Place the plastic lids around the cake where the wheels will go. Use the serrated knife to cut around the lids, cutting in just enough that the donuts will be recessed, about half the thickness of the donut. Dig out the remaining cake with a paring knife. On the front of the cake, cut out the mouth shape.
5. Use the pastry brush to brush away the crumbs all over the cake.
6. Use some of the leftover white frosting to glue the graham cracker halves to the back of the car. The crackers should stand up about 1 inch above the top.
7. Using the red frosting, spread a thin crumb layer all over the top, sides, front, back, and the crackers. Let the layer rest for a few minutes, then add the final layer which should be about 1/4-inch thick.
8. Put the donuts in place, positioning them so that they stick out about half way.
9. Spread the blue frosting on windows all the way around. The blue layer in the windshield is the glue for the white fondant.
10. Prep one of the plastic bags by attaching a #3 decorating tip. Add some white frosting to the bag. Roll and cut the white fondant using the X-Acto knife and the plastic drinking straws (for cutting the little dots). You’ll need a windshield shape, a round medallion for the top, a mouth, 4 detail dots for the hood, 2 rectangular shapes for the hood, 2 half ovals for the doors, and 4 larger dots for exhaust pipes under the doors. Use piped frosting to glue the fondant in place.
11. Prep another plastic bag by attaching a #3 decorating tip. Add some red frosting to the bag. Pipe the red around the windows along all of the edges, and with three stripes running down the back window.
12. Glue the round piece of brown fondant on the hood. Prep another plastic bag by attaching a #3 decorating tip. Add some orange frosting to the bag. On a piece of wax paper, practice piping the word Rusteeze, then when you are ready, pipe it onto the decal. Pipe the lightening bolts on the lalf-oval white fondant pieces on the doors.
13. Prep another plastic bag by attaching a #12 decorating tip. Add some blue frosting to the bag. Pipe two circles for the eyes.
14. Prep another plastic bag by attaching a #3 decorating tip. Add some black frosting to the bag. Pipe two black dots on the eyes. Pipe two white dots onto the eyes.
15. Glue the round piece of white fondant on the top of the car. Using the black frosting bag, pipe a number 95 on it.
16. Prep another plastic bag by attaching a #3 decorating tip. Add some blue frosting to the bag. Pipe five straight lines going down the back of the air dam.
17. Prep another plastic bag by attaching a #12 decorating tip. Add some red frosting to the bag. Pipe some frosting into the center of the donuts for the wheel axles.
[Disclosure: This blog earns a small commission through affiliate links.]