Subscribe to Andrea MeyersPostsSubscribe to Andrea MeyersCommentsSubscribe to emailsEmails

Key Lime Pie

June 1, 2007 by Andrea  
Filed under Dessert

Key Lime Pie

I was thwarted in my attempt to make an authentic key lime pie last weekend.

I’ve been trying to make a good, intensely-flavored key lime pie for several years. A few years ago I made my first pie on a whim when I spotted a bottle of Nellie and Joe’s in the grocery store. It was early summer and the thought of a refreshingly cold key lime pie grabbed me and I brought a bottle of the juice home. I used the recipe on the bottle, and I thought it tasted pretty good, but there just wasn’t enough lime for me. Thus began my quest for a more “limey” key lime pie, and I wanted the real thing with freshly squeezed key limes.

Well of course I could substitute the more common Persian limes, but they aren’t the same. The key limes have a stronger flavor that makes all the difference in a key lime pie. The bottled key lime juice is considered an acceptable substitute in a pinch, but I wanted the real thing with the zest and juice of some fresh key limes.

But key limes can be notoriously difficult to find unless you live in…Florida. Read more

Switch to our mobile site