SHF #22: Sweet Red Pepper Jelly

Print Friendly

Sweet Red Pepper Jelly - Andrea MeyersFollow Me on Pinterest

This month’s Sugar High Friday is hosted by Delicious Days and the theme is canning. I enjoy canning fruit jellies and jams as well as hot pepper jelly, but this sweet pepper jelly has to be my favorite. It’s a little sweet and a little tart and has the consistency of honey, a nice combination. It makes a great party appetizer poured over a slab of cream cheese and served with wheat crackers or sliced toasted baguette, although I enjoy it for breakfast or brunch on top of english muffins smeared with cream cheese. The color of the jelly will be a nice amber with red flakes, or if you prefer you can make it bright red by adding the optional food coloring.

If this is your first experience with canning, then take the time to read about the boiling water canning method and check out the resources mentioned in the post, including the list of canning cookbooks.

Update: Check out the round up of all this month’s canned sweets at Delicious Days.

Sweet Red Pepper Jelly
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
Serves: 6 half-pint jars
  • 3 cups finely chopped red bell pepper (in food processor or hand-chopped)
  • 1-1/2 cups apple cider or white vinegar
  • 6-1/2 cups white sugar
  • 4 ounces liquid pectin (not powdered)
  • 10 or more drops red food coloring (optional)
  1. Add the bell pepper, vinegar, and sugar to the sauce pan. Bring to a rolling boil and cook for 6 minutes, stirring constantly.
  2. Stir in the liquid pectin and continue to boil for 3 more minutes, stirring constantly. Skim off the white foam with with the metal spoon, and remove the pan from the heat.
  3. Ladle the jelly into the sterilized jars, leaving a 1/2-inch head space. Insert the plastic spatula next to the glass and run it carefully around the edges to help remove any air bubbles. Wipe the rims clean. Seal and process in a boiling water canner for 5 minutes.
More Information

sharp knife or food processor
4 quart stainless steel sauce pan
wooden spoon
stainless steel spoon
6 to 8 jelly jars (1/2 pint size)
lids and bands
canning equipment

Recipe Notes

Prep time and cook time do not include canning time.


[Disclosure: This blog earns a small commission through affiliate links.]


  1. Kathleen Harrison says

    I had tried a sample of red pepper jelly on the weekend and it tasted like there was oranges in it. It was very good. This is the only web site that I have found a recipe for it but to my surprize there is no oranges in it. Are there other recipes for red pepper jelly?

  2. says

    Hi Kathleen: Of course there are many recipes out there for red pepper jelly, but I didn’t see any in my arsenal or in a quick Google search that had oranges in it. However, I think you could have an orange flavor in the jelly simply by adding the zest of one orange. That is simple enough and certainly worth a try.

  3. Kathleen Young says

    I have a recipe for Hot Pepper Jelly. A friend and I made it one weekend and it didn’t jell. We thought possibly we had too much liquid from the peppers. A week later I tried making it again draining at least 2 cups of the liquid from the peppers. Still, it didn’t jell. Another friend made some ( a different recipe) and she had the same outcome. Again, last night I attempted it again taking time and being extra careful to follow the directions carefully. Still it didn’t jell! What am I doing wrong?!?! I’ve canned for years so this is not new to me. But this recipe has me stumped. Suggestions?

  4. says

    Hi Kathleen: Without seeing the recipe, I can only make a few guesses: not enough pectin, not enough sugar, or not enough cooking time for the mixture before canning.

    All that being said, some folks like their jellies to be a bit runny, so the recipe may be written that way. Again, I haven’t seen the recipe you are using, so I’m guessing at this point!

  5. Linda says

    Hi Kathleen: I have the same problem with my mulled apple cider jelly and have discovered that if I add an envelope of Knox unflavored gelatin, along with the pectin, the jelly actually gels. I don’t know if this will help with your hot pepper jelly, but it might be worth a shot.

  6. Brenda Monroe says

    Thank you for the recipe. I got a similar recipe from a friend some years ago and lost it; I have been frantic.
    Finally come across yours and it was very similar. The others I found were all hot jelly’s.
    We put green and red bellpeppers together for a Christmas and everyone loves my little jelly gift bags.
    Thank you so much for helping me get back on track.
    Plus I recieved an extra; the last batch I made didn’t jell either, now I know why.

  7. Lilas Marrier says

    I just made 2 separate batches of red pepper jelly the receipe is the same as yours except it called for 5 red peppers.
    Well, they must have been too big as it is runny as can be.
    Can I can this over again and do I need to add more pectin? Please help as these were supposed to be Christmas gifts.
    Thank you for any help you can give me.

  8. says

    Yes, you could can it over again. You’ll have to recook the jelly and either add more sugar or more pectin, both of which aid in setting. Make sure you do the spoon test (jelly should drip off the spoon in sheets rather than drops) before canning.

  9. Sylvia Smith says

    This recipe sounds great and I am anxious to try it, but I’m wondering if it can be frozen instead of canned.
    Thanks for a wonderful site.

  10. says

    Hi Sylvia. I’ve never frozen it so I can only speculate. The consistency of this jelly is like honey, not thick, so I’m not so sure it would freeze well. Of course now I’ll have to stick a jar in the freezer the next time I make it just to find out! :-)

  11. says

    Hi Jo. The jelly should keep for a couple weeks in the refrigerator, but if you use small half-pint jars, it shouldn’t be too worrisome. I have not tried freezing just because I make so much of it that it takes up too much freezer space. :-)

  12. Jo Guerisoli says

    Once the red pepper jelly is opened, How long will it keep in the refrigerator? Have you tried to freeze the jelly in containers without canning in jars?

    Thank you,
    Jo Guerisoli

  13. catherine tribble says

    I have a jar of sweet red pepper jelly, but i really like hot red pepper jelly. Can I add a few shakes of red pepper flakes or chili to spice it up a bit? or does the “hot” have to be added while it is cooking? (

  14. says

    Hi Catherine. For the best flavor, add the hot stuff during the cooking process. Stirring it in after opening a processed jar doesn’t hurt, but you won’t get quite as much flavor.

  15. Atha Kerr says

    This Jelly is not supposed to set, it is supposed to be runny, you put some cream cheese on a plate, dump some red pepper jelly over it and serve it with Wheat Thins.

    Atha Kerr

  16. Brooke says

    Hello Andrea! Well I took it upon myself to make your “Sweet Red Pepper Jelly” (for the first time)…and it turned out beautifully! Really pleased with the results. Great consistency, colour and flavour. Alongside this jelly, I also made a “Sweet Red Pepper/Garlic Jelly” of which hosted with other jarred jams and other preserves, will be given as gifts this Christmas. Thanks for a great recipe. It’s printed ready to make for next season.

  17. e says

    hi I followed this recipe exactly and its been three days and my jelly has not set. I have made many jelly’s including hot pepper jelly and it set….I am wondering how to do a redo?

    • says

      Hi e. As I mentioned in the header notes, this recipe doesn’t set up like a traditional jelly, it has the consistency of honey. It spoons out and drizzles nicely.

  18. chris says

    for sweet pepper jelly, is 4 oz of liquid pectin the amount in a certo pouch, or does it generally need to be measured out? thanks

  19. Alison Smith says

    Hi there! Last year, money being in very short supply, I gave preserves as gifts at Christmas…7 different kinds. Your pepper jelly was the winner, by a big margin. Thanks so much for the recipe. I am planning to make an even bigger batch this year, and skip all the other kinds of jellies etc. Money is even shorter this year. If things keep on like this, next year I shall grow the peppers myself, and start with one leg up. Thanks again.


  1. I’m hungry….!

    I just found this site with a whole row of Jams & jellies and other stuff on… and some of them look sooooo good….   Blueberry Port Chutney Shortbread Bars   Blueberry curd   sweet pepper jelly

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *